Math is Figure-Out-Able!
Math teacher educator Pam Harris and her cohost Kim Montague answer the question: If not algorithms, then what? Join them for ~15-30 minutes every Tuesday as they cast their vision for mathematics education and give actionable items to help teachers teach math that is Figure-Out-Able. See www.MathisFigureOutAble.com for more great resources!
Math is Figure-Out-Able!
Ep 230: Systems of Equations with Elimination (with sandwiches and cookies)
Don't you think math needs more cookies in it? In this episode Pam and Kim use Desmos graphing calculator to go through a routine to make sense of systems of equations before doing any elimination or substitution.
Talking Points:
- Kim going to a Cafe for sandwiches and cookies
- Graphing on Desmos graphing calculator
- Understanding x and y intercepts
- Understanding where the lines intersect
- Relating systems of equations to each other
Link to Desmos Graphing Calculator: https://www.desmos.com/calculator/qq59ey0bub
Check out our social media
Twitter: @PWHarris
Instagram: Pam Harris_math
Facebook: Pam Harris, author, mathematics education
Linkedin: Pam Harris Consulting LLC
Pam 00:00
Hey, fellow mathers! Welcome to the podcast where Math is Figure-Out-Able. I'm Pam, a former mimicker turned mather.
Kim 00:08
And I'm Kim Montague, a reasoner who now knows how to share her thinking with others. At Math is Figure-Out-Able, we are on a mission to improve math teaching.
Pam 00:16
I said, Pam. (unclear) Kim Montague.
Kim 00:18
(unclear). I was not listening because I was scrolling to find the intro.
Pam 00:22
To find what you were supposed to say. I love it. Well, well done. You made it there. That was good. We know that algorithms are amazing human achievements, but they're not good teaching tools because, ya'll, mimicking step-by-step procedures actually traps students into using less sophisticated reasoning than the problems are intended to develop.
Kim 00:38
In this podcast, we help you teach, mathing, building relationships with your students, and grappling with mathematical relationships.
Pam 00:45
We invite you to join us to make math more figure-out-able.
Kim 00:49
You want to know what I was thinking about while I was scrolling?
Pam 00:52
I do.
Kim 00:52
What the question that I asked you right before we got started. So...
Pam 00:56
I don't remember.
Kim 00:58
I said, "Hey, what math are we going to do today? What am I going to be doing?" And you said, "You're going to a cafe." And I was like, "That's not helpful. Okay. I have no idea what we're doing today."
Pam 01:09
Alright, yeah. So, Kim's going to be a little bit surprised maybe (unclear).
Kim 01:13
Talk about vulnerable, people.
Pam 01:15
Bam.
Kim 01:15
I don't even know what we're doing.
Pam 01:17
So much fun. Well, pretty soon you're going to do it to me, so that all will be fair.
Kim 01:21
Okay.
Pam 01:22
Okay, so a few weeks ago. Nira asked for some stuff with systems of equations. And I know we've taken our time, but I did kind of want to build some things with equations and equalities.
Kim 01:32
Mmhm.
Pam 01:32
Today, Kim, we are going to dive in and do maybe the coolest thing I've ever seen with systems of equations. And to be clear, I've seen some cool things.
Kim 01:41
Okay.
Pam 01:42
I'm totally going to give Kara Imm. a lot of credit. So, Kara was my co-author with the Algebra Problem Strings book. I had a super good time writing with her. She is... I think maybe you and I would call her one of the best Problem String facilitators.
Kim 01:57
Oh, yeah. I got to see her in New York. (unclear).
Pam 02:00
(unclear). I think you saw her twice maybe because you saw her. You saw her and then we saw her together. And...
Kim 02:05
Yeah.
Pam 02:05
...when we saw her together, we were like over on the side going, "Oh my gosh!" and we were comparing notes about things that she did and said. Yeah. So, thanks, Kara for that. Okay, so let's dive in to... Let's go to a cafe.
Kim 02:17
Okie doke.
Pam 02:17
So, Kim, you go to a cafe and you bought... You're buying for the crew.
Kim 02:23
Okay.
Pam 02:23
You bought 5 sandwiches and 4 cookies. I don't know who didn't get a cookie. It's not very nice of you, but. 5 sandwiches and 4.
Kim 02:30
4 cookies.
Pam 02:31
Yeah, 5 sandwiches and (unclear).
Kim 02:32
I only need four cookies.
Pam 02:33
Oh. For 5 sandwiches. Somebody eats (unclear).
Kim 02:36
Oh. I have boys in my house. That's... More sandwiches in an option.
Pam 02:40
Oh, gotcha.
Kim 02:40
(unclear).
Pam 02:40
Okay, alright. Or maybe it's me and I'm on a diet because that's always the thing.
Both Pam and Kim 02:45
Okay.
Pam 02:45
So, 5 sandwiches and 4 cookies. And you looked at the receipt, and those 5 sandwiches and 4 cookies cost $62.00.
Kim 02:53
Mmm.
Pam 02:54
Before you get going, going, going.
Kim 02:56
Mmhm.
Pam 02:57
Listeners, you might want to pause. So, Kim, don't say anything quite yet. Could you think of a possible price for the sandwiches and cookies that would get you $62.00? So, don't say anything too fast, but... I mean, I guess they can pause. But I'm just going to, you know like, just let you brainstorm.
Kim 03:21
Am I brainstorming?
Pam 03:22
Yeah. Can you think of a possible... Yeah, I'll let you talk. Yeah.
Kim 03:25
Okay, sorry. So, if the sandwiches were $10.00 bucks.
Pam 03:32
Okay.
Kim 03:33
Then, that would be $50.00 of my dollars. So, then that means the 4 cookies would cost $12.00, and so they would be $3.00 each.
Pam 03:42
Oh, nice.
Kim 03:43
So, it's $10.00 sandwich, and $3.00 cookie.
Pam 03:45
Nice, and that makes the total lots of sense.
Kim 03:48
Mmhm.
Pam 03:49
Do one more, just for grins. What if the sandwiches were like a $1.00
Kim 03:52
Oh, I put $2.00.
Pam 03:54
Okay, or that. Or that.
Kim 03:55
So, if they were really bad, $2.00 sandwiches, then that would be $10.00.
Pam 04:00
Okay.
Kim 04:01
Out of my $62.00 bucks, so then $52 for cookies.
Pam 04:06
Oof!
Kim 04:06
Holy cow! So, 4 cookies for $52.00, that would be $13.00 bucks for a cookie (unclear).
Pam 04:12
I so want to know how you just did that, but we're not going to go there today.
Kim 04:15
Okay.
Pam 04:16
Okay. Cool. Nice. So, we could continue to do that, right? (unclear) like. In fact, one way that sometimes I'll do with kids. They're like, "Nah, I don't do numbers." I'll just say, "Well, what if the sandwiches were free?"
Kim 04:21
Yeah, yeah. (unclear).
Pam 04:21
Or what if the cookies were free? Yeah, just get them started, kind of thinking about some possibilities. We could brainstorm some possibilities, kind of get a sense for that. And then we could kind of ask ourselves like, "How many possibilities are there?" And as we talk about how many possibilities there are, we're going to use technology today to kind of look at all those possibilities. Now, Kim is a self professed not...
Kim 04:21
Yeah, yeah. Not techie.
Pam 04:54
Not...
Kim 04:54
No tech.
Pam 04:55
Okay.
Kim 04:56
I'll say that.
Pam 04:57
So, we're just going to like... It will work. So, we're in a Desmos, online graphing calculator.
Kim 05:03
Yep.
Pam 05:03
Neither of us can see each other, so we're going to (unclear)...
Kim 05:05
Uh-oh, okay. (unclear).
Pam 05:07
...what we're saying. Kim, if we were to just type in kind of what we just said which was 5 times the cost of the sandwiches. So, I'm going to put 5x. And x is going to represent the cost of the sandwiches.
Kim 05:19
Okay.
Pam 05:20
Plus. Because we're going to add it to the cost of the cookies.
Kim 05:22
Yep.
Pam 05:23
Plus 4 times y. And we'll let y be the cost of the cookies. Now, Desmos users, we could have put s and c. We could have.
Kim 05:31
Oh, I was going to ask about that. Okay.
Pam 05:33
We could have. I don't know why I'm not today. Today, I'm not.
Kim 05:36
It's fine.
Pam 05:36
And then when we sum those up on the bill, it was $62.00 Is that right?
Kim 05:40
Mmhm.
Pam 05:41
Yeah? So, I just typed equals $62.00 What do you see, Kim. So, 5x plus 4y equals 62.
Kim 05:46
I see a portion of a line.
Pam 05:49
Yeah.
Kim 05:50
Yeah.
Pam 05:51
So, what...
Kim 05:53
My screen goes from -10 to 10.
Pam 05:57
And about -9 to... Yeah, about -10 to 10, yeah. That's the home screen usually.
Kim 06:03
Yeah, can I... You going to let me...
Pam 06:05
I am going to. Yes.
Kim 06:05
...find more. Okay.
Pam 06:06
Yeah, yep. What...
Kim 06:08
I'm going to zoom out because I want to see more of the line. And I kind of am interested where they cross the axis.
Pam 06:15
So, you have this gut instinct.
Kim 06:16
Yeah.
Pam 06:17
That there's something kind of cool about where they cross the x-axis. Okay. Can you just hover over like where it crosses the x-axis? What is that point?
Kim 06:26
I have (12.4, 0)
Pam 06:30
And any idea what that means in this cookie, sandwich? Yeah, what does it mean.
Kim 06:34
If I bought 12.4 cookie...sandwiches? Oh, I need the s. 12. 12. It would be $12.40 for a sandwich and 0 cost for the cookie.
Pam 06:46
Hey, there's the free cookie.
Kim 06:48
Yeah.
Pam 06:48
There's the free cookie. So, listeners, you think about while Kim goes and looks for it. What about the y-intercept? Like, where it's 0. And then I'm seeing 15.5. What does that represent in this sandwich, cookie scenario?
Kim 07:04
Tell me the numbers you got. I think I lost it. Oh, here we go. Oh, man.
Pam 07:12
You're so stinkin' fun.
Kim 07:13
If I pay $0.00 for sandwiches, then my cookies are $15.50. That's never happening for me.
Pam 07:19
Bam. That's never... You would not do that?
Kim 07:21
(unclear) for a cookie. That's crazy. was (unclear). I mean, if it Maybe it's a cookie cake! It's a cookie cake.
Pam 07:25
Ooh, a cookie cake. Okay.
Both Pam and Kim 07:26
Alright.
Pam 07:26
I was going to say or really good chips and salsa. You would totally do that.
Kim 07:29
Oh, for sure I would.
Pam 07:30
Yeah, okay.
Kim 07:32
Cool.
Pam 07:32
So, I wonder if we could find one of your... You had said $10.00 for a sandwich and $3.00 for a cookie. Can you find that point on that line? Where would that be?
Kim 07:46
Yeah, but I kind of want... Like, I'm just like guessing. Like, why am I guessing? I need to go find it. That's silly.
Pam 07:54
Like, can you? If I'm looking at the line, and I literally took my cursor and I'm putting it on the line where x equals 10. You know, on the line. And it's sure enough, it's (10, 3). There it is. So, that's... There's one of the ones that you found. We could go find the other one. So, we can kind of have this conversation about how there's a lot of possibilities. In fact, if we let this line be, there's sort of an infinite set of possibilities. Now, if we round it off for money, then not so much. But there's a lot. A lot a lot of possibilities about what those sandwiches and cookies could cost. Cool. Alright, Kim, that was our first problem. Second problem. What if you went in and this time you bought 4 sandwiches and 5... Oh, golly, golly, golly. So, on my paper, I have written... Well, actually, on the board, I would just have the Desmos graph. 5x plus 4y equals 62.
Kim 08:43
Mmhm.
Pam 08:44
On my paper, I wrote 5s plus 4c equals 62.
Kim 08:47
Mmhm.
Pam 08:48
For the second problem, I wrote 4s plus... Did I say 5 cookies?
Kim 08:52
No.
Pam 08:52
4 sandwiches plus 5 cookies. And I mean, we just switched, so it should also be $62.00, right? Nope. Nope. Today it was $55.00. One less sandwich, one more cookie, and it costs less. Does that tell you anything? I'm just kind of curious. $55.00, yeah.
Kim 09:08
Say that again? It's 1 less sandwich and 1 more cookie. Oh, I wrote $62.00 again. It's how much? $55.00 1 less sandwich and 1 more cookie, and it's less. So, the sandwiches are more expensive.
Pam 09:21
How do you know that?
Kim 09:24
Because I have the same amount of things and it costs less. Like, when I added 1 more cookie and had 1 less sandwich, the price went down $7.00.
Pam 09:35
Yeah, so that sandwiches. Another way to look at it is to go from the one we just said. If you add a sandwich and take away a cookie, it went up by a lot. So, that's kind of interesting. Okay, cool. Do you think... What do you think that... How do I say this? Could we find some other possibilities for the price of sandwiches and the price of cookies?
Kim 09:56
Yeah, you mean like on using Desmos. Like, you were to... I mean, I could come up with some random ones.
Pam 10:02
Yeah.
Kim 10:03
You like me to?
Pam 10:05
Or... Yes. So, I might like look for one. Do you have one? Well, I have a fun one. What if the sandwiches were free?
Kim 10:14
Okay.
Pam 10:15
So, 4 sandwiches are free. 5 cookies cost $55.
Kim 10:19
They're $11.00 bucks.
Pam 10:20
Bam. So there's a... And where would we expect to see that? So, let's go ahead and type it now into Desmos. So, here's a different...
Kim 10:26
Do I need my original line? (unclear)
Pam 10:27
Yes, please keep your original one. Thank you. Great question. So,
Kim 10:30
You're wondering if I... Oh, there. I did it. Okay, good for me.
Pam 10:31
what did you type in?
Kim 10:35
I haven't typed it in yet. I was excited that I found number two. Clearly, I do not do anything with Desmos.
Pam 10:43
I love it.
Kim 10:43
Thank goodness my kids just...
Pam 10:46
They just come home and teach you all the Desmos.
Kim 10:48
They do. They don't pay for that. Okay.
Pam 10:50
Alright.
Kim 10:50
Alright. New line. Green line.
Pam 10:52
Yep. Okay. And what did you type in?
Kim 10:55
4x plus 5y equals 55.
Pam 10:58
Do you dare try to tell me what that means?
Kim 11:02
5... 4 sandwiches and 5 cookies is $55.00 bucks.
Pam 11:05
Okay. And if I could 4 sandwiches times the price of the sandwiches plus (unclear)...
Kim 11:11
Oh yeah.
Pam 11:11
...times the price of the cookies is $55.00. Okay. And so, now that I'm assuming it graphed. And what do you see? Can you just describe for everybody what you see?
Kim 11:19
The line is shallower than the previous line.
Pam 11:25
Okay.
Kim 11:25
Like it's less slope.
Pam 11:27
Can you find that that cookie price when we said the sandwiches were free and the cookie was $11?
Kim 11:34
Um.
Pam 11:36
Yeah. Maybe we should have put s and c.
Kim 11:38
No, it's okay. So, I have (0, 11). I'm hovering over (0, 11). That's $0.00 cost for sandwiches and $11.00 for cookies.
Pam 11:47
Nice, nice. And there's the intercept right there. And we could go look at the other intercept. It looks like it's not even. I've got (13.75, 0). So, I think that means, if the cookies were free and the sandwiches would cost $13.75 each. And then there's all sorts of possibilities in between.
Kim 12:07
Mmhm. Oh, I scrolled out enough, and then there's more to see. Haha. I was zoomed in too much still. So, the intersect.
Pam 12:15
Tell me your window now because I kind of want you to stay in the window that I'm in.
Kim 12:18
I'm in -25 to 30 on that x-axis.
Pam 12:24
Oh, you moved around. I think that'll still work. Maybe don't. Maybe don't move around anymore.
Kim 12:28
Okay. I was pretty zoomed in.
Pam 12:30
Okay, okay.
Kim 12:31
I didn't see that they intersected.
Pam 12:34
Intersected. So, they do intersect. The two. And what's the intersection point?
Kim 12:39
(10, 3).
Pam 12:40
And what do you think that means that (10, 3)
Kim 12:47
At $10.00 for the sandwich and $3.00 for the cookie. I think. It's $55.00 bucks. That's... Yeah, that's $55.00 bucks.
Pam 12:59
Okay.
Kim 12:59
But it's also when there's... What does that mean in the other line?
Pam 13:06
Yeah, what does that mean?
Kim 13:06
$10.00 for the sandwiches and $4.00 for the cookies. No, 5 sandwiches and 4 cookies and 4 sandwiches and 5 cookies? That's where they are equivalent. Or they intersect.
Pam 13:19
What does it mean that those two... Like, one day I went to the cafe and I got 5 sandwiches and 4 cookies, and another day I went to the cafe and I got 4 sandwiches and 5 cookies. And they intersect.
Kim 13:29
They cost the same.
Pam 13:31
So, you think we're at the same cafe?
Kim 13:34
No, because one was $62.00 and one was $55.00, right?
Pam 13:38
Yeah, but we bought different stuff.
Kim 13:42
Oh, yeah, we did. Haha.
Pam 13:43
What does the point (10, 3) mean? Like, that's the only place these two lines intersect, right?
Kim 13:49
Mmhm.
Pam 13:51
And I think you said for the second day we went in you said... Okay, so I bought 4 sandwiches at $10.00 each, and 5 cookies at $3.00 each, and it costs $55.00. And you can see that point there is (10, 3).
Kim 14:03
Mmhm.
Pam 14:04
But it's also on the other line. If I bought 5 sandwiches at $10.00 each, and 4 cookies at $3.00 each, it cost $62.00.
Kim 14:13
I don't think I understand what you're asking.
Pam 14:14
Oh, maybe not. Sorry. I'm wondering what that point means for our scenario. And maybe you've already said it. When we did the first line, we had lots of different possibilities.
Kim 14:26
Sure.
Pam 14:27
That the sandwiches and cookies (unclear) costs. When we did the second line, we had other possibilities (unclear).
Kim 14:31
(unclear). So, this point, when I had the first cafe, it was $10.00 for the sandwiches and $3.00 for the cookies. And that's that point, (10, 3). So, in this scenario, it would be the $10.00 sandwich and the $3.00 cookie would be $55.00. Is that what you're asking?
Pam 14:49
I think so.
Kim 14:50
That's the price of the sandwiches and cookies when I...
Pam 14:54
On both days.
Kim 14:55
Yes.
Pam 14:55
Yeah, that's what I was trying to get at.
Kim 14:57
Oh, sorry. I'm sorry.
Pam 14:59
So, we'll belabor it a little bit.
Kim 15:00
Didn't I say it was the price?
Pam 15:01
Probably.
Kim 15:02
Oh, okay.
Pam 15:03
Yeah, sorry.
Kim 15:03
Sorry.
Pam 15:04
Okay.
Kim 15:04
It's okay.
Pam 15:05
So, then you go back another day, and this day you bought 6 sandwiches.
Kim 15:09
6 sandwiches.
Pam 15:10
And 3 cookies. And today your bill was $69.00. And I'm curious, how that... Do you think you're in the same cafe?
Kim 15:18
Oh, that's a good question.
Pam 15:18
And what are you thinking to figure that out?
Kim 15:19
I think that if the sandwiches were $10.00 bucks, that would be $60.00 bucks. And if the cookies were $3.00 bucks, that would be $9.00 bucks. And so, yes, I'm at the same cafe.
Pam 15:23
Oh, so you tried it. You're like, "Let's stick it in there." What would it look like... Nice. What would it look like if you graph that line that represents 6 sandwiches and 3 cookies costing $69.00. Predict first.
Kim 15:44
You want me to predict first?
Pam 15:45
I do, yeah. If you don't mind. And, listeners, at home predicting what might that line look like.
Kim 15:50
So, I think the line where the second day the line was shallower of a slope. This time it's going to be a steeper slope.
Pam 16:00
Oh, interesting. Well, let's see if it is.
Kim 16:04
Find the third one. 6x plus 3y.
Pam 16:10
Equals $69.00
Kim 16:13
Equals $69.00 Indeed.
Pam 16:15
Bam. And when you said "indeed", it's steeper. Is there anything else that pops out at you?
Kim 16:21
The... I don't know the right word. The space between them. The steepness is...
Pam 16:29
Kind of mirrored?
Kim 16:30
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Pam 16:31
Okay, alright, (unclear).
Kim 16:32
Same change of slope.
Pam 16:33
Same symmetry going on. Okay. Or some symmetry going on. Anything else pop out at you like where that point (10, 3) was?
Kim 16:42
It's at 0. There's a... Oh, what about it? It's (10, 3). Yes.
Pam 16:46
Do all three lines now intersect in (10, 3)?
Kim 16:49
Yep.
Pam 16:49
So, we're in the same cafe. You already kind of said that numerically, but we can also kind of like. There's lots of...
Kim 16:55
I love sandwiches at this place apparently. I go three days in a row, but they're the same price, so that's exciting.
Pam 17:01
So, it's interesting that if I just said, Kim, you bought 6 sandwiches and 3 cookies, and they cost $69.00, could you have found lots of different combinations? Yes. But as we look at these different days at the cafe, you're getting different. There's lots of different possibilities for each one of them. But as we graph them, they're all intersecting in the same (10, 3), which means the price of the cookies and sandwiches has not changed.
Kim 17:22
Right.
Pam 17:23
Let's do one more. How about 3 sandwiches and 6 cookies. And that costs $48.00
Kim 17:29
Okay.
Pam 17:30
Cool.
Kim 17:30
That makes sense.
Pam 17:31
Alright. And why does it make... What makes sense to you?
Kim 17:34
Well, I'm thinking that the sandwiches are $10.00 bucks, so that's $30.00.
Pam 17:37
Okay.
Kim 17:39
And then the cookies are $3.00 bucks, so that's $18.00.
Pam 17:43
Sure enough, yeah.
Kim 17:44
And that's $48.00.
Pam 17:46
Cool. And what might that line, if you were to predict that line, what might it look like?
Kim 17:50
It's going to be the most shallow. Why do you say that? What
Pam 17:53
is it about the things? You've kind of said "shallow" and "steep", but we haven't really talked about why? What about them?
Kim 18:00
When the price of the sandwich goes down... Man, how do I say this? The price of this... The number of sandwiches that I buy, goes down, it really reduces the total price more than if I were to buy 1 less cookie. Like...
Pam 18:21
And that's... Yeah, sorry. Go ahead.
Kim 18:22
Yeah. I was just going to say because the sandwiches are more expensive when I buy 1 less of them, my total bill goes down more drastically.
Pam 18:28
Yeah.
Kim 18:28
Than if I were to just buy 1 less cookie at the time.
Pam 18:32
Yeah. And at some point you said something about a 7.
Kim 18:37
Did I?
Pam 18:37
Remember when that was? Yeah, I wish I would have hung on to it better. But...
Kim 18:41
Oh, the change in price is $7.00 because sandwiches are $10.00 bucks, and the cookies are $3.00, so the change overall is $7.00 bucks.
Pam 18:52
So, like if you look between the original price of $62.00 and the next day's price of $55.00, there's a $7.00. And then from that original price of $62.00 to the third day price of $69.00, there's a change of $7.00. So, when we went up by a sandwich and down by a cookie, or vice versa, there was this change in 7 that was happening.
Kim 19:10
Right.
Pam 19:11
Which may or may not tell us the 10 and the 3, but it's kind of interesting that we kind of have that change in 7 going on. Cool. And did you graph 3x plus 6y equals 48? That fourth one?
Kim 19:20
No, but I'm doing it right now.
Pam 19:21
Whoo!
Kim 19:22
Slow, but I'm there. Okay.
Pam 19:24
You're doing great. And does it intersect at (3, 10)? So...
Kim 19:31
Yeah.
Pam 19:31
Yep, got the same kind of thing going on? Cool. So, I could continue to keep giving you different sandwich numbers and different cookie numbers, and we could continue to see that because the cost of the sandwiches, the cookies aren't changing...
Kim 19:44
Yeah.
Pam 19:45
...that they are continuing to intersect at that intersection point. We could continue to look at different slopes changing. We could also look for some other patterns in the numbers that I give you. And one of those patterns that I'm just going to sort of mention because we're going to keep this podcast tight here today is I could have asked you 8 sandwiches and 10 cookies.
Kim 20:07
Mmhm.
Pam 20:07
2 sandwiches and 7 cookies. And then I could have asked you for 10 sandwiches. So, maybe I'll just repeat the sandwiches in a row. I could have asked you for 8 sandwiches one day, given you the cookies and the cost. Then I could have asked you for 2 sandwiches, given you the cookies and the cost. Then I could have given you 10 sandwiches, given you the cookies and the cost. And a thing that I would have you notice, that I would ask questions about, is that you could actually add that 8 sandwich day and that 2 sandwich day to the 10 sandwich day, and notice some relationships happening. You could notice that you can actually add these orders together, and the cost of the sandwich and the cookies doesn't change. In other words, you can add the equations of lines together and the intersection point stays the same. And that was a huge stumbling block for me when I was learning systems of equations because they would say, "Here are two lines that are not the same in any way, but they intersect. Now, add them together, and you'll get a third line. And do stuff with it." And I was like, "I'm sorry, what?"
Kim 21:15
Yeah.
Pam 21:15
"You want me to add lines together and you're telling me that that has something to do with these first two lines?" It had made no sense to me that you could add equations of lines together, and that it would maintain the intersection point. You get a whole new line. It's not the same line.
Kim 21:32
Right.
Pam 21:32
It's just that... So, if you could look at kind of the spider that I have on my Desmos right now, I have lots of different equations of lines. They're all intersecting at that one (10, 3) because the price of the sandwich and the cookies didn't change, even if I made sure that I added different orders together and got different final prices. As long as that intersection point, or the price in the sandwich and the cookies, doesn't change, then I have a system of equations that's still equivalent. Which means they still have the same intersection point. How cool is that?
Kim 22:03
Yeah. That's super cool.
Pam 22:05
Whoo!
Kim 22:05
Super cool.
Pam 22:07
Another thing that we could do if we had more time with this, and that I've done with with students in the past, is to kind of keep... At first, I kind of messed with the numbers not very systematically, but I could over time kind of get to where I had 2 sandwiches and 7 cookies, give you the price. Then I could down the sandwich and up the cookies. So, 2 sandwiches and 7 cookies, then I could down it and go 1 sandwich and 8 cookies. And then I could say, "Well, then let's down it one more time. What about 0 sandwiches and 9 cookies." And, bam, you've got the price for cookies.
Kim 22:41
Mmhm.
Pam 22:41
Right, because now you've got this sort of 0 thing happening. And I could have gone the other direction and walked back until I had 0 cookies and just sandwiches equaling that price. And then we could kind of solve for the sandwich price. So, ya'll, I would suggest that this is a fantastic task to do with students to have lots of ideas come together and really get kids thinking about systems of equations and making sense of it way before you do anything to have them think about graphing to find the solution, or using elimination, or using substitution. That this is the groundwork for systems. And it's hugely the groundwork for elimination. Bam! Alright, ya'll, stay tuned, and we'll do more systems of equations coming up soon. So, thanks for tuning in and teaching more and more real math. To find out more about the Math is Figure-Out-Able movement, visit mathisfigureoutable.com. And keep spreading the word that Math is Figure-Out-Able!